[alsa-devel] How to propagate parameters from FE to BE with compressed audio interfaces
Pierre-Louis Bossart
pierre-louis.bossart at linux.intel.com
Wed Nov 14 17:51:56 CET 2018
Hi Daniel,
On 11/14/18 9:35 AM, Daniel Baluta wrote:
> Hello,
>
> soc_compr_set_params_fe calls dpcm_be_dai_hw_params in order to setup
> BE hw_params.
>
> Is there a way to transfer parameters like for example the rate from FE
> to BE?
>
> In soc_compr_set_params_fe there is this code:
>
> *
> * Create an empty hw_params for the BE as the machine driver must
> * fix this up to match DSP decoder and ASRC configuration.
> * I.e. machine driver fixup for compressed BE is mandatory.
> */
> memset(&fe->dpcm[fe_substream->stream].hw_params, 0,
> sizeof(struct snd_pcm_hw_params));
>
> So, information about parameters is just ignored.
>
> The only way we can setup hw_params for BE is via
> be_hw_params_fixup() but this function doesn't have any information
> from FE.
>
> My use case is something like this:
>
> FE:
> - cpu: FSL SAI DAI interface
> - platform: DSP
> - codec: dummy codec
> BE:
> - cpu: dummy
> - platform: dummy
> - codec: cs42888.
>
> codec could handle 44100Hz and 48000Hz streams, but the BE doesn't have
> any way to know what is the rate cplay sets to FE.
I don't think we planned for the case you mention, but IIRC it was
intentional.
In our implementations and the non-Intel ones I am familiar with, the BE
typically handles data that is mixed between PCM channels (for
tone/alerts/low latency) and decompressed data. So the rate adaptation
of the decoder output is handled inside the DSP and the BE is configured
at a set rate. I also don't remember when was the last time we supported
44.1 kHz, maybe 2011?
You *could* add support for dynamic BE reconfigurations but then it
creates a headache for the mixer usages. Not to mention that decoders
support rates that the BE may not support so SRC is likely required
anyways. And I forget schemes like AAC+ implicit signaling where you
first have to decode before figuring out if you have valid SBR data
which will result in a 2x upsampling of the output - in other words you
may not necessarily know what the output frequency of the decoder is
just by looking up the file so doing a configuration at the DPCM level
is complicated at best.
-Pierre
More information about the Alsa-devel
mailing list