Re: [alsa-devel] multiple, non-physically accesible, HDMI devices listed for Intel IbexPeak ALC269VB
On 02/23/2012 01:01 AM, Andres Cimmarusti wrote:
If the new two pins can be never used, i.e. physically unreachable, we may disable these pins by giving the proper default pin-config values. Usually it's a job of BIOS. But if BIOS doesn't do it, user need to do it manually.
Build your kernel with CONFIG_SND_HDA_HWDEP=y, CONFIG_SND_HDA_RECONFIG=y, CONFIG_SND_HDA_PATCH_LOADER=y. I guess most of distro kernels are built with them. Then create a file containing below in /lib/firmware, such as, /lib/firmware/ibx-hdmi:
================================================================ [codec] 0x80862804 0x80860101 3 [pincfg] 0x04 0x411111f0 0x06 0x411111f0 ================================================================
Now pass this file to "patch" module option for snd-hda-intel. For example, create a file in /etc/modprobe.d/, e.g. /etc/modprobe.d/50-hdmi.conf, containing the line
options snd-hda-intel patch="ibx-hdmi"
Then reload the driver or reboot. This will disable pins 0x04 and 0x06 so that only the pin 0x05 will be used.
I've tested this workaround and it works well. I don't suppose this could be added as a quirk to the kernel for this particular device? (when and only if there's only one physically accessible HDMI connector).
Stephen, could you comment on this? Are we guaranteed a certain board configuration (i e which pins are physically connected or not) given a PCI SSID, or anything else that can be used as a key to a quirk table? I think I've asked you before and that the answer was "no", but my memory could be failing me.
There are ways to configure pulseaudio to allow the user to select which PCM device to use on a given sound card. David Henningsson made this work for NVIDIA GPUs at least in Ubuntu, and I imagine the same technique could be applied to Intel devices too.
Mmm.. just in Ubuntu? was this work submitted upstream? It appears there are some related fixes shown in the Ubuntu pulseaudio changelog:
http://changelogs.ubuntu.com/changelogs/pool/main/p/pulseaudio/pulseaudio_1....
I found a thread related to this issue here: http://www.mail-archive.com/pulseaudio-discuss@mail.0pointer.de/msg07433.htm... Started by yourself Stephen Warren! but it doesn't seem like it got anywhere...
As Takashi mentions, from a kernel perspective, this isn't really a regression at all, but simply exposing all the features of the HW that were previously hidden. Without that change, others can't use some HW usefully at all. Unfortunately, pulseaudio makes some rather simplistic assumptions about how HW works by default, and can be confused by the additional features that are exposed.
Agreed. But in the case of laptops, I don't think I've ever seen one that actually has more than one physical connector. I'm a little puzzled as to how all these outputs (in my case 3) make sense for my hardware...
Even if there is only one HDMI output, it's it not that uncommon, actually. Many DVI outputs can output HDMI audio as well (when connected through an HDMI monitor through DVI->HDMI adapter), and DisplayPort also has audio support.
David Henningsson wrote at Thursday, February 23, 2012 1:31 AM:
On 02/23/2012 01:01 AM, Andres Cimmarusti wrote:
If the new two pins can be never used, i.e. physically unreachable, we may disable these pins by giving the proper default pin-config values. Usually it's a job of BIOS. But if BIOS doesn't do it, user need to do it manually.
Build your kernel with CONFIG_SND_HDA_HWDEP=y, CONFIG_SND_HDA_RECONFIG=y, CONFIG_SND_HDA_PATCH_LOADER=y. I guess most of distro kernels are built with them. Then create a file containing below in /lib/firmware, such as, /lib/firmware/ibx-hdmi:
================================================================ [codec] 0x80862804 0x80860101 3 [pincfg] 0x04 0x411111f0 0x06 0x411111f0 ================================================================
Now pass this file to "patch" module option for snd-hda-intel. For example, create a file in /etc/modprobe.d/, e.g. /etc/modprobe.d/50-hdmi.conf, containing the line
options snd-hda-intel patch="ibx-hdmi"
Then reload the driver or reboot. This will disable pins 0x04 and 0x06 so that only the pin 0x05 will be used.
I've tested this workaround and it works well. I don't suppose this could be added as a quirk to the kernel for this particular device? (when and only if there's only one physically accessible HDMI connector).
Stephen, could you comment on this? Are we guaranteed a certain board configuration (i e which pins are physically connected or not) given a PCI SSID, or anything else that can be used as a key to a quirk table? I think I've asked you before and that the answer was "no", but my memory could be failing me.
Any quirks would definitely have to include the PCI subsystem vendor ID and subsystem device ID to stand any chance of working; the main dev and vendor IDs certainly aren't enough.
For NVIDIA GPUs, my expectation is that matching on all 4 IDs would often provide a unique key that determines which quirks to apply. However, the subsystem IDs are assigned by OEMs, and I have no idea whether they re- use the same IDs for different boards sometimes (I believe they shouldn't, but that doesn't necessarily mean anything). I assume the situation is identical for Intel graphics chips, but I can't really comment there at all!
In summary: Our GPUs have a bunch of output port pins, and it's up to the individual board design which of those to use for which ports. There should be a 1:1 mapping between the 4-part PCI ID and the set of ports used and what for, but there's no way to guarantee that's true across all boards.
Finally, if we did start quirking this, a complete table would end up being potentially enormous; an entry for every graphics board or mother- board with integrated graphics ever made...
participants (2)
-
David Henningsson -
Stephen Warren