Hi,

I wrote PortMIDI long ago and now that it's going into Audacity and we're having timing problems in Linux, I'm revisiting the code and wondering if ALSA has a fundamental design problem. I'm hoping I'm missing something, but here's the problem:

PortMIDI wants to send MIDI messages at precise times according to arbitrary clocks. In Audacity, the important clock to synchronize to is the audio sample clock. To synchronize MIDI, one can in principle use timestamps and let the device driver, which presumably runs with very low latency, dispatch MIDI from a queue to the device or destination. The question is then what timestamp to use. ALSA has some options. There's relative timing, but if you send with relative time and you get unscheduled just as you are executing the write call, you'll be late. There's absolute timing, but the docs say that's relative to when you start the queue, but when exactly is that? The problem becomes precise timing of queue creation doesn't it? And there's no timestamp provided for when to start. If "absolute" mean exactly the system time, that would be great, but I think that's not the case.

Is this a fundamental design error, or am I missing something?

Thanks. -Roger Dannenberg