Hi,
On Fri, 6 Mar 2015, Pavel Machek wrote:
Our take was that ALSA is not the right interface for cmt_speech. The cmt_speech interface in the modem is _not_ a PCM interface as modelled by ALSA. Specifically:
- the interface is lossy in both directions
- data is sent in packets, not a stream of samples (could be other things than PCM samples), with timing and meta-data
- timing of uplink is of utmost importance
I see that you may not have data available in "downlink" scenario, but how is it lossy in "uplink" scenario? Phone should always try to fill the uplink, no? (Or do you detect silence and not transmit in this
Lossy was perhaps not the best choice of words, non-continuous would be a better choice in the uplink case. To adjust timing, some samples from the continuous locally recorded PCM stream need to be skipped and/or duplicated. This would normally be done between speech bursts to avoid artifacts.
Packets vs. stream of samples... does userland need to know about the packets? Could we simply hide it from the userland? As userland daemon is (supposed to be) realtime, do we really need extra set of timestamps? What other metadata are there?
Yes, we need flags that tell about the frame. Please see docs for 'frame_flags' and 'spc_flags' in libcmtspeechdata cmtspeech.h: https://www.gitorious.org/libcmtspeechdata/libcmtspeechdata/source/9206835ea...
Kernel space does not have enough info to handle these flags as the audio mixer is not implemented in kernel, so they have to be passed to/from user-space.
And some further info in libcmtspeechdata/docs/ https://www.gitorious.org/libcmtspeechdata/libcmtspeechdata/source/9206835ea...
Uplink timing... As the daemon is realtime, can it just send the data at the right time? Also normally uplink would be filled, no?
But how would you implement that via the ALSA API? With cmt_speech, a speech packet is prepared in a mmap'ed buffer, flags are set to describe the buffer, and at the correct time, write() is called to trigger transmission in HW (see cmtspeech_ul_buffer_release() in libcmtspeechdata() -> compare this to snd_pcm_mmap_commit() in ALSA). In ALSA, the mmap commit and PCM write variants just add data to the ringbuffer and update the appl pointer. Only initial start (and stop) on stream have the "do something now" semantics in ALSA.
The ALSA compressed offload API did not exist back when we were working on cmt_speech, but that's still not a good fit, although adds some of the concepts (notably frames).
Well, packets are of fixed size, right? So the userland can simply supply the right size in the common case. As for sending at the right time... well... if the userspace is already real-time, that should be easy
See above, ALSA just doesn't work like that, there's no syscall for "send these samples now", the model is different.
Br, Kai