Hi Stephen,
On 26/08/11 20:44, Stephen Warren wrote:
Liam, Mark,
I was recently talking to our internal audio team, extolling the virtues of writing upstreamable drivers for Tegra's audio HW.
One of the big unknowns here is how to represent the Tegra DAS and AHUB modules[1] in a standard fashion, and allowing configuration via kcontrols that influence DAPM routing, rather than open-coding and/or hard-coding such policy in the ASoC machine driver.
So, my questions are:
- What's the status of the ASoC DSP work. I see that some of the base
infra-structure has been merged into ASoC's for-next branch, but I think that's just a small portion of the work. Do you have any kind of estimate for when the whole thing will be merged? I don't see recent updates to e.g. Liams' topic/dsp or topic/dsp-upstream branches.
I have about 10 Dynamic PCM (AKA ASoC DSP) core patches still to make it upstream atm.
It in progress atm, but will probably slow down for the next 2 weeks since I'll be in California.
I am aiming to upstream asap, but other things usually take higher priority than upstream at times.
- Back in March in another DSP-related thread, Mark mentioned that the
DSP rework was mainly about configuring stuff within a device, but that Mark was working on some code to support autonomous inter-device links. I assume that Tegra's DAS/AHUB would rely on the DSP work, not the stuff Mark mentioned?
If the Tegra hardware is on CPU and looks anything like the OMAP4 ABE then you will probably need the Dynamic PCM code.
http://www.omappedia.org/wiki/Audio_Drive_Arch
The ABE is basically a PCM DSP with SRC, ASRC, Mixers, Muxes, Volumes, Mutes and DAIs implemented in FW.
Liam
See the last few paragraphs of: http://mailman.alsa-project.org/pipermail/alsa-devel/2011-March/037776.html
Related, Mark also mentioned something about representing the DAS/AHUB as codecs. I'm not sure if that was meant as a stop-gap solution before the DSP work was in place, or if that's part of supporting DAAS/AHUB within the DSP infra-structure.
Thanks for any kind of information! Any information here will simply help us plan for when we might be able to switch from open-coding some of the more advanced Tegra audio support to more standardized solutions.
[1] Here's a very quick overview of the relevant Tegra audio HW:
DAS:
Part of Tegra20. Tegra20 has Digital Audio controllers (DACs) i.e. I2S controllers. It also has Digital Audio Ports (DAPs). The Digital Audio Switch (DAS ) sits between. Each DAP selects its audio output from a particular DAC's or DAP's output. Each DAC selects its audio input from a particular DAP. DAP<-> DAP is supported, with one being the master the other the slave. Note that I2S configuration (channels, sample size, I2S vs. DSP etc) is configured in the DAC not the DAP.
AHUB:
Part of Tegra30. Tegra30 has an interconnect called the Audio HUB (AHUB). Various devices attach to this: FIFOs to send/receive audio to CPU memory using DMA, DAMs that receive n(2?) channels from the AHUB and mix/SRC them sending the result back to the AHUB, and finally various IO controllers such as I2S and SPDIF. The AHUB is I believe a full cross-bar. In this case, the I2S formatting is configured solely within the I2S controllers, not on the other side of the AHUB as is the case with the Tegra20 DAS. FIFOs also independently determine the number of channels/bit they send/ receive. There is some limited support for channel count and bitsize conversion at each attachment point to the AHUB. I2S<->I2S loopback may be supported in HW, at least in some cases.