[alsa-devel] caiaq driver: audio 4 dj and jackd
daniel at zonque.org
Mon Dec 2 17:00:13 CET 2013
On 12/02/2013 04:15 PM, Gabriel M. Beddingfield wrote:
> On 12/02/2013 01:59 AM, Daniel Mack wrote:
> Jack has always opened only one PCM device... which is the Right Thing
> for most recording sound cards (e.g. ice1712, hammerfall, etc.). This is
> the first "pro-sumer" device I've ever seen with multiple substream devices.
I was also uncertain when I wrote the driver which way is better. But
given that there are ways in ALSA to synchronously start separate
streams, I eventually went the stereo pairs way.
>> After all, the streams are guaranteed
>> to be synchronous, as they share the same clock in hardware.
> TBH, the whole substream concept is lost on me. Where does this
> guarantee come from? From the substream concept or from intimate
> knowledge of this device?
> (I.e. how would JACK know about the clock
snd_pcm_info_get_sync() should return the same clock id for both
interfaces in that case. But I must admit I haven't tried this in awhile.
>> Technically yes, but changing that would mean breakage for all other
>> users, and making it configurable would result in yet another moving
>> part which makes things even more complex.
> How would this cause breakage? Users that use 2 stereo substreams could
> still work normally.
Yes, unless you opened the first subdevice with more than 2 channels.
Then an existing user for the second stream breaks. IOW: the possible
configuration and usage for subdevice 1 changes depending on that of
> But, FULL ACK on the moving parts. That would indeed make the driver a
> little gross on the inside.
What are your results with the multi plugin? Is that something you can
More information about the Alsa-devel